Most of these gifts were wrapped in brown craft paper from Hobby Lobby. Some of them were wrapped in a vintage owl print paper. The gifts were paired with silver tinsel bows and cream and silver ribbon from Hobby Lobby. I purchased the Mr. Men and Little Miss books on Amazon and Barnes and Noble. A description of the series and a list of all of the books can be found here.
On Christmas morning, I placed out all of my gifts. I then told my family to choose which gift that they thought was theirs based off of the "tag." Although they quickly determined which one was theirs, they loved the idea. They each had fun reading their books as well. I definitely recommend using this wrapping idea. Lots of fun!